Why most retail traders lose money

The ads show winners; the research shows a large majority of losers. The causes are known, measured, and mostly avoidable.

By the PastFolio editors8 min readLire en français
Cartoon from 1903: a bear brandishes a sword over a fallen bull, before the Wall Street crowd

The ads show traders winning from their sofa. The research tells another story: across most of the markets and periods studied, a large majority of individuals who trade actively lose money. It is not inevitable, but you need to understand why before hoping to do better.

What the numbers say

Regulators and researchers have measured the phenomenon several times, on different products and in different countries. The results look alike.

StudyPopulation observedResult
AMF (France), 2014Retail forex traders, 2009-201289% lost money, average loss ≈ €11,000
ESMA (Europe), 2018Retail CFD accounts74 to 89% of accounts lose money
Barber and Odean, 200066,000 US households, 1991-1996Most active: 11.4% a year, vs 17.9% for the market
Chague et al., 2019Brazilian day traders active for over 300 sessions97% lost money

Since 2018, European CFD brokers, who sell highly leveraged products, have had to display on their website the share of retail accounts that lose money. It is usually above 70%.

Fees: a slope to climb every day

Every order costs something: a commission, the spread between the buying and selling price, sometimes financing charges. One by one, these costs look negligible. Multiplied by the number of orders, they become the active trader’s first opponent.

That is Barber and Odean’s conclusion: the households that traded the most did not necessarily pick worse stocks, but their costs wiped out most of their return. Fewer orders is often better.

10,000 after one year of fees alone (0.1% per order)

1 round trip a month9,7631 round trip a week9,0121 round trip a session6,0645 round trips a session820
No market losses at all, only fees: the more orders you place, the steeper the slope to climb. Over 250 sessions, five round trips a day leave less than a tenth of the capital.

Leverage, the ruin accelerator

The products most sold to individuals, CFDs and forex above all, work with leverage: you commit far more than your stake. With leverage of 20, a 5% move against you is enough to lose the whole amount committed.

Leverage does not improve decisions: it speeds up their consequences. Beginners are often wrong; that is normal. With leverage, those ordinary mistakes leave no time to learn.

Up against better-equipped professionals

Over short periods, trading looks like a zero-sum game before costs: what one side wins, another loses. And on the other side of the screen are funds, banks and high-frequency algorithms with better data, lower costs and faster execution.

Trying to beat them over a few minutes means playing on their turf. Individuals have other strengths: no one to report to every quarter, the ability to wait, and the freedom to do nothing.

A crowd packed into a Wall Street street during the panic of 1907
Wall Street during the panic of October 1907. When fear takes hold of the crowd, individuals often sell at the worst moment.Anonyme, octobre 1907 · Public domain · source

Biases: the brain against the portfolio

Behavioural finance has shown that our natural reflexes are poorly suited to markets. Three biases weigh especially on retail traders.

  • Overconfidence. A few wins are enough to feel gifted. You trade more, raise your stakes, and both fees and losses grow.
  • The disposition effect. You sell winners quickly to “lock in” the gain and hold losers hoping to get back to your purchase price. The result: small gains and large losses (see when to sell a stock).
  • Chasing the big hit. Following a rumour, a forum or a stock that has just jumped 50%, often too late, just as the first buyers start selling.

How to be in the minority

There is no guaranteed method, but the same habits show up among those who do better than average.

  1. Trade less often. Every order needs a written reason, not just an urge.
  2. Limit the risk per position. A common rule: never risk more than 1 to 2% of your capital on a single idea.
  3. Decide the exit before the entry: at what price you will admit you were wrong, and why.
  4. Avoid leverage until you have proven yourself without it.
  5. Keep a journal: every order, its reason, its result. You learn more from mistakes written down than from memories.
  6. Practise first. Mistakes cost less on a simulator.

In PastFolio, fees are charged on every order and tomorrow stays unknown, as on a real market. The end-of-game summary compares your result with the scenario’s index: you see whether your activity earned you something, or cost you.

Educational content, not investment advice.

Also worth reading

Engraving: a clockwork automaton reading a strip of ticker tape, its gears exposed

10 min read

Micro-trading algorithms, explained simply

A large share of orders on stock markets comes from algorithms that decide in a few microseconds. How do they make money, and what do they change for everyone else?

Read the article →
Engraving: a young clerk leaning over a ledger, holding a strip of ticker tape

11 min read

What to know before you start trading

Before you place your first order, a handful of concepts make all the difference between learning and losing. Here they are, without jargon, with the numbers that matter.

Read the article →