When should you sell a stock? The good and bad reasons

Buying is easy; selling forces a decision. Studies show that individuals sell their winners too early and hold their losers too long. Here is how to decide with a cool head.

By the PastFolio editors7 min readLire en français
A broker in a top hat reads a stock ticker tape, in 1894

Buying is easy: you have an idea, a hope, a story. Selling is much harder, because selling forces a decision. With a gain, you fear leaving too early; with a loss, you refuse to admit it. Most beginners do not have bad buying ideas; they simply have no exit plan.

A man in a top hat reads the tape of a stock ticker
In 1894, a broker reads prices off a ticker tape. The question has not changed since: hold, or sell?William Thomas Smedley, 1894 · Public domain · source

The purchase price trap

The market does not know what price you paid, and does not care. Yet that price takes up almost all the room in an investor’s head: you wait to “get back to even” before selling a loser, or you sell a winner as soon as it shows a nice percentage.

The only useful question looks forward: if I did not own this stock today, would I buy it at this price? If the answer is no, holding it amounts to buying it again every day.

The disposition effect: selling winners, holding losers

Terrance Odean measured it in 1998 on 10,000 US retail accounts: investors sold their winners about one and a half times more readily than their losers. And it was a bad bet.

Five good reasons to sell

  1. The reason you bought no longer exists. You bought for the growth of a product that has been dropped, for a CEO who is leaving, for a contract that was lost: the story has changed, the stock must be reassessed.
  2. Your loss threshold has been hit. The level at which you decided, before buying, to admit you were wrong.
  3. The position has grown too big. A stock that has doubled can take up an outsized share of the portfolio. Trimming it back to your target allocation is diversification in practice.
  4. You have found something better. Money tied up in one stock is not working elsewhere. A better idea, clearly argued, is a valid reason to switch.
  5. You need the money. Hence the value of only investing sums you will not need in the short term, so that this reason comes as late as possible.

The stop: an exit decided in advance

The simplest way to escape biases is to decide your exit before you get in, with a cool head. That is what a stop is for.

A fixed stop stays at a set level, for example 10% below the purchase price. A trailing stop rises with the price: it always stays 10% below the highest level reached, and never moves down. It protects both against losses and against giving back all your gains.

Fixed stop and trailing stop

exitpricefixed stop at −10%trailing stop 10% below the high
Bought at 100. The fixed stop stays at 90; the trailing stop rises with the price and never moves down. When the stock turns, it takes you out with a gain, where the fixed stop would have given back the whole rise.

Two limits to know. A stop set too tight triggers on plain noise: place it with the stock’s volatility in mind. And a stop does not guarantee the price: if the stock opens sharply lower after bad news, the order fills at the first available price, sometimes well below the threshold.

The bad reasons to sell (or to hold)

What you tell yourselfWhat really happens
“I’ll wait to get back to my purchase price”Your purchase price has no influence on the future price
“I’ll lock in my gain, that’s good enough”You sometimes cut your best ideas too early
“Everyone is selling, so am I”Panics make people sell near the lows
“It has risen too much, it has to fall”A rising stock can keep rising for a long time
“I’ll stop looking, it will come back eventually”Some stocks never come back

Finally, think about tax: selling a winning position realises a capital gain, usually taxable depending on the type of account and the country. It is a cost to factor in, never a good enough reason to hold a stock you no longer want.

Writing your exit rule

The best selling decision is made when you buy. Before each order, write down three lines:

  • Why I am buying: the idea, in one sentence.
  • How I will know I am wrong: a price threshold, or an event.
  • What I will do if all goes well: trim beyond a certain weight, or follow with a stop.

PastFolio does not execute automatic orders: it is up to you to apply your threshold at each session, watching how your positions moved. An excellent exercise in discipline, with no risk at all, before doing it with real money.

Educational content, not investment advice.

Also worth reading

Cartoon from 1903: a bear brandishes a sword over a fallen bull, before the Wall Street crowd

8 min read

Why most retail traders lose money

The ads show winners; the research shows a large majority of losers. The causes are known, measured, and mostly avoidable.

Read the article →
Engraving: a three-masted ship tossed by a raging sea under lightning

Explainer · 3 min read

What is volatility?

Two investments can return the same and feel completely different. Volatility measures the storm you will sail through on the way.

Read the explainer →
Engraving: a young clerk leaning over a ledger, holding a strip of ticker tape

11 min read

What to know before you start trading

Before you place your first order, a handful of concepts make all the difference between learning and losing. Here they are, without jargon, with the numbers that matter.

Read the article →