Currency: when the exchange rate decides your return

Buying a foreign stock means making two bets at once: on the company, and on its currency. The second often goes unnoticed, until the day it wipes out the first.

By the PastFolio editors8 min readLire en français
Flemish painting: a money changer weighs coins on a scale, his wife leafing through a book beside him

When a European saver buys an American, Japanese or Swiss stock, they are not only taking a risk on the company. They first exchange their euros for another currency, and one day they will have to make the return trip. In between, that currency will have moved, sometimes as much as the stock itself.

Reading an exchange rate

When EUR/USD rises, the euro strengthens: each dollar you hold is worth fewer euros. When it falls, the opposite happens. These moves depend mostly on interest rates set by central banks, on growth and on crises: in a panic, investors often take refuge in the dollar, the Swiss franc or the yen.

Two bets in one

The return on a foreign investment, measured in euros, combines two moves: that of the asset in its own currency, and that of the currency against the euro. They roughly add up.

A US stock seen from Europe

100 $87.0 €95.2 €the euro rises from 1.05 to 1.15 $price in dollarsvalue in euros
The stock does not move in New York, but the euro strengthens: for a euro-based investor, it loses nearly 9%.

A stock that does not move in New York can therefore lose money for a European investor, simply because the dollar has fallen. Conversely, a strengthening dollar can cushion a fall.

2017 and 2022: two real examples

YearS&P 500 in dollarsEUR/USD over the yearS&P 500 in euros
2017+19%from 1.05 to 1.20about +5%
2022−19%from 1.14 to 1.07about −14%

In 2017, the US index gained nearly 20%, but the euro soared: a European saver kept only about a quarter of it. In 2022, the opposite happened. The index lost nearly 20%, but the dollar strengthened so much that the euro fell below parity in the summer: in euros, the loss was only about 14%.

Can you protect yourself?

  • Hedged funds: some ETFs come in a “currency-hedged” version. They neutralise most exchange-rate moves, at a cost that depends on the interest-rate gap between the two currencies.
  • Diversification: holding assets in several currencies stops any single one from weighing on the whole portfolio.
  • Time: over long periods, currency effects tend to partly cancel out, with no guarantee that they will.

Watch the fees too: many brokers take a commission on each conversion, often a few tenths of a percent, on top of trading fees.

Currency in PastFolio

Each game has its own game currency, chosen at the start. Assets stay priced in their home currency: dollars for Wall Street, yen for Tokyo, pounds for London. Your balance, average costs and performance are converted at the real exchange rate of the simulated day. A US stock can therefore rise in New York and weigh on your euro portfolio, exactly as in real life. The scenario called The Orient, with its Asian exchanges, is especially sensitive to it.

Educational content, not investment advice.

Also worth reading

Engraving: a crowd of agitated brokers on Wall Street, 1908

Explainer · 3 min read

What is a stock market index?

A single number to say how a market is doing. But not all indices are calculated the same way.

Read the explainer →
Engraving: a wicker basket full of rolled, ribbon-tied certificates on a table

Explainer · 3 min read

What is an ETF?

A whole index in a single share, for a few cents of fees a year. Why ETFs changed the way people invest.

Read the explainer →
Engraving: a young clerk leaning over a ledger, holding a strip of ticker tape

11 min read

What to know before you start trading

Before you place your first order, a handful of concepts make all the difference between learning and losing. Here they are, without jargon, with the numbers that matter.

Read the article →